Culture Blogs

Undermining the Patriarchy Every Chance I Get. And I Get a Lot of Chances

  • Home
    Home This is where you can find all the blog posts throughout the site.
  • Tags
    Tags Displays a list of tags that have been used in the blog.
  • Bloggers
    Bloggers Search for your favorite blogger from this site.
  • Login
    Login Login form

Pagans! Politicize this Tragedy!

Posted by on in Culture Blogs

After the terrible shootings in Aurora, Colorado, proponents of allowing mental patients to buy and carry assault weapons warned Americans in favor of gun control not to "politicize" the tragedy.  Similarly, after Hurricane Katrina, Bush administration officials insisted that "now is not the time to play the blame game."  It's become an expected response anytime something bad happens:  Don't Politicize the Tragedy!  

Which is odd, when you think about it, because, in a democracy, politics is how we go about trying to address national problems.  And when a tragedy brings some problem (gun violence, global climate change, underfunded relief agencies, etc.) to the forefront of our attention, that seems like a great time to start talking seriously about the problem.

And, of course, admonitions aside, tragedies do get politicized all the time.  Jerry Falwell and Pat Robertson blamed the ACLU and the First Amendment, as well as Pagans, "abortionists," feminists, and homosexuals for the September 11th attacks.  Fox News has worked pretty tirelessly to politicize the deaths of Americans in Benghazi.  And before Hurricane Sandy had even made landfall, the Christian right wing was blaming homosexuals for the storm.

What does all of that have to do with Pagans?

Pagans honor and, in many cases, worship Earth.  Our religious holidays revolve around the seasons and we view trees, rivers, landbases, watersheds, and the Elements as sacred -- in many cases as alive components of a greater whole. We see ourselves as an interconnected part of this whole, not as separate from, and superior to, it.  

And in most cases, our politics reflect these beliefs.   

We tend to accept the science on global climate change, understanding that human activity and overpopulation are causing, or at the very least exacerbating, the problem.  We tend to support policies that will help alleviate, for example, dependence on carbon fuels, a focus on perpetual growth as the basis of our economy, monculture as the basis for our food supply.  For many Pagans, issues related to ecology are very important. We can, and certainly do, differ over the precise answers to these problems, but Pagans, as a group, are often more focused upon these problems than are the members of many other religions. 

Yet both major political parties usually place these issues on the back burner.  The recent set of debates between Governor Romney and President Obama failed to focus on global climate change, leaving a casual observer to imagine that the issue is unimportant.  Even as weather events of the very sort predicted by climate change scientists become more and more frequent and more and more dangerous, our politicians sit by and do little more than debate whether the response to such events should be privatized or the cost of response offset by cuts to other government programs.  A political issue of huge importance to most Pagans is routinely trivialized and ignored.

And, as Americans begin today to assess the damage done by Hurricane Sandy, anyone suggesting that now is a good time to start talking seriously about climate change is told not to "politicize" the tragedy.  I think that's advice that Pagans would do well to ignore.  It's long past time to begin to take seriously what our dependence upon, and gross misuse of, fossil fuels is doing to the planet.  It's long past time to begin to take seriously what human overpopulation is doing to a finite planet with finite carrying capacity.  It's long past time to being to take seriously the species of plants and animals that we are driving rapidly into extinction.  It's long past time to begin to take seriously what we're doing to the oceans, the ice caps, the Amazon rainforest.  And if a tragedy such as Hurricane Sandy can get Americans to focus on that, maybe it won't be an unallayed disaster after all.

So don't be muzzled by the "politically correct" notion that it's somehow wrong to politicize a tragedy.  Now is a great time to get others to focus on an issue that has, for too long, been almost as ignored as Paganism, itself.              

Last modified on
Tagged in: Politics
HecateDemeter is a woman, a Witch, a mother, a grandmother, an ecofeminist, a lawyer, a gardener, a reader, a writer, and a priestess of the Great Mother Earth.


  • Byron Ballard
    Byron Ballard Tuesday, 30 October 2012

    Yes! I will do my best to politicize this occurrence (after all these years in theatre, I have a different definition of tragedy). Wise woman--I am grateful for you.

  • Hec
    Hec Tuesday, 30 October 2012


    You are right; "tragedy" does have a diff meaning in theatre. I am grateful for your wise, womanly wisdom, as well. Blessed Samhein to you and yours.

  • Makarios Ofiesh
    Makarios Ofiesh Tuesday, 30 October 2012

    If I might venture to suggest a slightly different framing of the issue: talking like responsible adults about matters of demonstrable, and demonstrated, scientific fact is not "politicizing" those facts. It is the GOP and the religious right (to the extent that those two groups can be distinguished), primed by funding from the fossil fuel industry, who have turned the issues surrounding anthropogenic climate change into a political football and a battleground in their culture wars. They, and not the people who are calling for a serious discussion of possible solutions, are the ones who have "politicized" it.

  • Constance Tippett Chandler
    Constance Tippett Chandler Wednesday, 31 October 2012

    This why we need a strong central government with regulations. Can you imagine a privatised FEMA? We would be charged to be saved, or we couldn't be saved because problems with their insurance, or it wouldn't be cost effective. Yikes!! Their quest to privatize everything, has invented a new type of capitalism. Take the tax payers money, charge billions, put most of it in your pocket, and provide shoddy service without those pesky regulations. I remember my republican sister during the Gulf oil spill saying, " Why doesn't the government just step in an do something?" Because the gov didn't have the technology. Their had turned it over to the ones that broke it, plus they didn't regulate it well.
    The political is personal!! Seem s like they don't want to politicize disasters, just body parts.

  • Please login first in order for you to submit comments

Additional information