Paganistan: Notes from the Secret Commonwealth
In Which One Midwest Man-in-Black Confers, Converses & Otherwise Hob-Nobs with his Fellow Hob-Men (& -Women) Concerning the Sundry Ways of the Famed but Ill-Starred Tribe of Witches.
Are Easter and Ishtar Related?
Contrary to what you may read in the local papers a few weeks from now, there's no historical connection between Easter and Ishtar.
Easter is the modern English name of the pan-Indo-European Dawn Goddess, also known as Ostara, Aušrine, Austra, Aurora, Eos, Ushas, and by many other names. All these names clearly derive from the Proto-Indo-European root for 'east.'
Ishtar is the Akkadian ('Babylonian') name of the pan-Semitic goddess known to the Greeks as Astarte, the Phoenicians as 'Ashtárt, and the Hebrews as 'Ashtóreth (originally 'Ashtéret). The name's original meaning remains unclear.
There's no known historical connection between these goddesses (or, better perhaps, families of goddesses). One is Indo-European, the other Semitic.
The fact that the Indo-European name is clearly derivable from an Indo-European root precludes the possibility that Indo-European speakers could have borrowed her from Semitic cultures. Although the origin of the Semitic name remains unclear, the fact that the goddess was already known among Semitic-speakers before their initial contacts with Indo-European-speaking peoples precludes the possibility of borrowing in the other direction as well.
Although both the Semitic and Indo-European goddesses have strong erotic connotations, the Semitic goddesses have no known association with Dawn.
Funny though, that similarity of names.
If we know anything about the gods, we know that they have a sense of humor.
For more on the Dawn-Goddesses of Indo-Europeandom and the Semitic Love/War Goddesses, see:
Paul Friedrich, The Meaning of Aphrodite (1978). University of Chicago.
Incidentally, Friedrich's theory is that the Greek Aphrodite is, in effect, the daughter of the IE Dawn Goddess and the Semitic Love Goddess. (Being goddesses, of course, they can easily manage such things.)
Above: Ashtoreth (artist unknown)
Please login first in order for you to submit comments